The Latest Skinny on Soul Mates

The Latest Skinny on Soul Mates

I totally believe that my husband and I are soul mates. But what does that mean exactly? To expand on my own ideas, I’m sharing sections of a piece by Ada Calhoun that appeared in TIME. Her recent book is the memoir WEDDING TOASTS I’LL NEVER GIVE.


The idea of soul mate goes back to Plato’s Symposium. Zeus, thinking to humble humans, split them in half, forcing us to wander in search of our other half. As Calhoun writes, this mythological concept is VERY ROMANTIC, but has kind of messed us up–as some people keep searching, denying that a happy, healthy relationship fits that bill–and casting about continuously for THE ONE.

Calhoun admits to thinking she had met the magical one–only to discover in the bright light of reality that no–if he was her soul mate, they are definitely over-rated.


J.R.R. Tolkien loved his wife from his teens until her death at the age of 82. But he also had some interesting things to say about our obsession with soul mates and blamed it on the Romantic Tradition. He wrote: “Its weakness is, of course, that it began as an artificial courtly game, a way of enjoying love for its own sake…It takes, or in the past has taken the young man’s eye off women as they are–that is companions in shipwreck…not guiding stars.” 

Such a great statement and so realistic. Life can never be all positives. It’s when the loved person is there when things get tough, when there’s some kind of shipwreck, that real love comes through. Long-lasting love affairs, Calhoun writes, are about time, patience and commitment. Possibly years of dating can also develop these ties that bind. In the end, you are a kindred spirit or the soul mate, because of true knowledge of the other, forgiveness, and consistent love and understanding.


In her piece, Calhoun writes about a friend’s parents who appeared to be soul mates, but really didn’t have much to bind them together. “She was Jewish, and he had a good job. That was enough for the marriage to begin.” But they struggled while raising their family and talked about separating when that part of their lives was completed. But what had happened during that time? When the children were grown, they discovered that neither wanted to leave the marriage.


I can only speak from the one marriage that has blessed my life. When we started out, we were both working, but SILLY ME insisted that I take over the household chores, because my husband came from a large family and had already had a large share of domestic life. He bought me a washer and dryer a month after our wedding. YAY. We had a small townhouse (thank you Park Forest, Illinois) with hardly any yard to mow. To save money, I made lunches for me to take to my teaching job and he to take to his insurance adjuster job in downtown Chicago.

The lunch thing ended abruptly for my husband when in front of co-workers, he opened a sandwich of liver sausage on raisin bread. I was fired! (That’s all I had in the fridge.) But you see, we were developing a marriage. I was forgiven and yet a fable was born.

I fired him from lawn mowing because “I’ll do it on the weekend” just didn’t work in a Chicago spring when it rained every weekend and the grass was a foot high. GIVE AND TAKE.

Like the saying that a cold with medication lasts two weeks and one without medication lasts 14 days, our marriage is solid. No one could have provided for me better, loved me more and fathered our children with constant care, understanding and humor than he. A photographer, trip planner, universal fixer, wine connoisseur, film partner and of course loving husband–he is mine. A total blessing. We decided a few years ago, that marriage should feel comfortable, like a worn and beloved pair of slippers. Anxiety is out. Our home is warm and companionship reigns and he always remembers to set the light timer and check the smoke detectors!! Good will abides within our home.


Tolkien believed “The real soul mate is the one you are actually married to.” That makes sense to me. The years of discovering this person within a marriage–his and her depths, beliefs, weaknesses and strengths–is like water flowing against a rock or a tree growing against a wall. Throughout the years, the give and take forms and shapes us within the relationship. We learn when to push ahead and when to pull back. As Calhoun states in her piece, THE IDEAL PARTNER IS THE ONE YOU CREATE.

Photo: TIME MAGAZINE online





12 thoughts on “The Latest Skinny on Soul Mates

  1. Splendid!!!! From this Boomer Highway, a soul mate might not be the other half of your kindred spirit, but someone who evolves into it……I like that thought. To pretend that in any relationship there aren’t peaks and valleys is naive. But to appreciate, face, and deal with them grows two people together….”two branches on one tree.” That is cozy.

  2. I have never believed in soulmates. I had a friend who was in awe that she and her husband found each other. as their soul mates. I never understood her awe because they went to school together and the same church! Their marriage did not last.

    • Yes, you can believe in some miracle without any groundwork to make it so. Marriage is a formation that builds over time. Sometimes it works. Sometimes it simply does not. Thanks, Haralee.

  3. I am not sure on this one..I thought I had found mine and then he was gone…so were we? But I know people who have found theirs so maybe it is true…

    • Renee, in all relationships, I think it’s more true about BECOMING the soul mates. In your case, it was not to be. There’s no harm in that discovery. You are you and lovely at that. Thanks, Beth

  4. Great post! As an author of romance novels, I’m definitely a believer. As a wife of 37 years, blessed with a wonderful husband and enduring marriage, I know that the reality of “soul mate” means both parties being fully invested in the relationship, willing and able to listen, compromise, forgive, and hold tight. I feel sorry for people who, for whatever reason—sometimes outside of their control—are unable to maintain a relationship long enough to get to the really good stuff.

    • I love your reference to THE REALLY GOOD STUFF, because you are right, getting through the bumps brings you to the rewards. So glad for your romance novels and your marriage. Thanks.

  5. I LOVE THIS Beth! And so beautifully written too: “The years of discovering this person…[are] like water flowing against a rock or a tree growing against a wall.” Lucky us! We know for sure what a soul mate is because we have one!

    • Ah, Laura, you are so right. John is doing well, we have a new doctor for him. He still volunteers 2-3 days a week while I, lazy me, write. Keep those photos of the glories of Colorado coming, Beth

  6. Hi Beth! I am of two (or three) minds about the whole “soul-mate” idea. Some days I know without a doubt that Thom and I were destined to be together. Other days I just think it was pure luck that brought us together those 40 years ago. Still other days, I’m aware of the amount of determination and compromise it takes to continue to work toward creating a quality relationship. But one thing I do know for sure is that something brought us together 40 years ago that was beyond my knowing or understanding and call it destiny, kismet or soul-mates, we are just about to celebrate our 40th and I am very aware that what most people call a nice marriage does not describe the depth of connection and love I feel for the man I call my partner. Obviously we are all different in personality and temperament so what one might find fulfilling might work for them–and not for others. What is important is finding what’s right for us. I am just so gratefull that I did and it sounds like you are too! ~Kathy

  7. Hi Kathy, so good to hear from you. YES! As I wrote in my piece, certainly when we make that vow we are not alike–maybe in some ways, but certainly not in all ways. Connection and love–so beautiful as it grows and compliments your own life. Congrats on 40 years. I celebrate you and Thom. John and I are similarly blessed with our 47 years. We should all have such a marriage.

Leave a Reply to Lisa Ricard Claro Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *